All-or-nothing thinking

(also called black-and-white thinking, polarized thinking, or dichotomous thinking) is a cognitive distortion where people interpret situations in extreme categories, without recognizing shades of gray or middle ground.

Key Points:

  • Rigid categories: Things are seen as either perfect or a failure, good or bad, success or disaster.

  • Common in negative self-talk: Example → “If I don’t get an A, I’m a complete failure.”

  • Distorts reality: Ignores nuance, making it harder to see partial success, progress, or balance.

  • Linked to mental health issues: Frequently appears in anxiety, depression, perfectionism, and low self-esteem.

  • Reinforces stress: Creates pressure to be flawless and fuels cycles of disappointment.

  • Cognitive restructuring helps: Challenging these thoughts and replacing them with more balanced perspectives reduces their impact.

Implications:

All-or-nothing thinking narrows perception and amplifies emotional distress. By noticing it and practising more flexible thinking (e.g., “I didn’t do perfectly, but I did better than last time”), people can reduce self-criticism, build resilience, and approach challenges with greater balance.

————————————-

Critical thinking

is the skill of carefully and logically examining information, ideas, or situations before accepting them as true or making a decision. It’s less about what you think, and more about how you think.

Key elements of critical thinking:

  • Questioning assumptions – Not taking things at face value.

  • Analysing evidence – Looking for facts, data, and reasoning rather than relying only on opinions.

  • Recognizing biases – Noticing personal, social, or cultural influences that might distort judgment.

  • Considering alternatives – Exploring multiple perspectives or solutions before concluding.

  • Logical reasoning – Making sure conclusions follow from the evidence, avoiding fallacies.

  • Reflective judgment – Asking “Does this make sense?” and “What’s missing?” instead of rushing to agree or disagree.

Core Techniques

  • Ask Clarifying Questions

    • Example: “What evidence supports this claim?” or “What do you mean by that?”

  • Evaluate Evidence

    • Check reliability of sources, biases, and data quality before forming a conclusion.

  • Consider Multiple Perspectives

    • Explore alternative viewpoints instead of sticking to your first assumption.

  • Identify Assumptions

    • Ask: “What am I taking for granted here?”

  • Analyse Cause and Effect

    • Look for actual relationships, not just correlations.

  • Break Problems into Parts

    • Tackle complex issues by dividing them into smaller, more manageable pieces.

  • Think in Probabilities, Not Absolutes

    • Replace “I’m 100% sure” with “It’s likely” or “It’s possible”.

  • Recognize Cognitive Biases

    • Watch out for confirmation bias, all-or-nothing thinking, or emotional reasoning.

  • Use “Devil’s Advocate” Thinking

    • Argue against your own idea to test its strength.

  • Reflect and Self-Correct

    • Be willing to revise your views when new evidence arises.

Implications

Applying critical thinking techniques improves decision-making, reduces errors caused by bias, and strengthens problem-solving skills. It shifts thinking from reactive and emotional to systematic and evidence-based. Over time, this leads to clearer communication, more balanced judgments, and greater confidence in navigating complex issues.

——————————————-

Voicing Your Thoughts Out-loud

Why Does That Work?

Here’s why voicing your thoughts out loud can be powerful, especially in a CBT context:

  • Externalises inner dialogue – Saying thoughts out loud makes them feel separate from the self, easier to observe and question.

  • Engages multiple senses – Hearing your own words activates auditory processing, reinforcing awareness beyond just thinking silently.

  • Slows down automatic thinking – Speaking is slower than thinking, which forces you to articulate more clearly and reflect more deeply.

  • Highlights distortions – When negative or irrational thoughts are spoken, they often sound exaggerated or illogical, making them easier to challenge.

  • Strengthens learning – Speaking thoughts aloud can consolidate new coping strategies and reinforce alternative, healthier beliefs.

  • Can reduce intensity – Verbalizing strong emotions sometimes lowers their power, much like venting to a trusted friend.

  • Mimics therapeutic dialogue – Even outside of sessions, voicing thoughts can recreate the CBT process of examining and disputing unhelpful beliefs.

Implication:
Speaking thoughts out loud creates distance from them, helps detect cognitive distortions, and promotes a more balanced perspective. It’s like having a mini “therapy session” with yourself, training your brain to slow down, evaluate, and reshape unhelpful thinking patterns.

———————————————

Why journaling can help

Here’s a clear breakdown of why journaling helps in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT):

  • Increases self-awareness – Writing down thoughts and emotions makes patterns more visible. People can spot unhelpful thinking styles (e.g., catastrophising, black-and-white thinking).

  • Slows down racing thoughts – Putting worries on paper creates distance, making them easier to evaluate logically rather than react emotionally.

  • Strengthens thought–emotion links – Journaling helps connect situations, thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, which is the core of CBT.

  • Supports cognitive restructuring – Once unhelpful thoughts are identified, they can be challenged and reframed in writing.

  • Reinforces progress – Recording successes, coping strategies, and small wins helps track growth over time.

  • Acts as exposure – Writing about feared situations can reduce avoidance and make them feel less overwhelming.

  • Provides material for therapy – Journals give therapists and clients concrete examples to work with during sessions.

Implication:
Journaling works in CBT because it externalizes thoughts, making them more objective and less overwhelming. It turns abstract feelings into something concrete, which allows people to examine, challenge, and change unhelpful patterns. Over time, this strengthens emotional regulation and builds healthier coping skills.